Sell Your Home with the Team Who Does More

The Power of a Team

When you list your home with The Reynolds Team, you get an entire team working on getting your home sold! Let us introduce you to our amazing team.

Proven Track Record of Home Sales

357 Homes Sold in 2022
$164 Million Dollar Volume Sold in 2022
#10 Ranked in Florida in 2022 by Real Trends
Talk to us about selling your home

Exceptional Service with 350+ Five Star Google and Zillow Reviews

Get In Touch With Us
10+ Reviews
10+ Reviews
7+ Reviews

Thinking About Selling?

Find Your Home's Value in Today's Market, for Free.

Meet Jesse Hatmaker

Setting the standard for excellence in the local real estate community.

Contact Jesse
Jesse Hatmaker
Jesse Hatmaker REALTOR® (772) 332-4119

Jesse Hatmaker, Realtor with The Reynolds Team of CompassJesse has called Vero Beach home since 1992 after living in Louisville, Kentucky and several states along the East Coast, from New York to the Carolinas. He studied theater at Indian River State College and was a drummer in a rock band. No stranger to hard work and determination, Jesse has held several successful careers including CFO of a major finance corporation and working in long haul Truck Driving. With over 23 years of sales experience running a successful call center, Jesse developed expertise in negotiating and closing transactions. Those skills combined with his trustworthy and outgoing demeanor made a transition into real estate a natural fit. Jesse’s clients easily connect with him and find his wealth of local knowledge a huge asset, giving them confidence during their home purchase or sale.

Jesse and his wife Jessica, a third generation Vero Beach native, are a fun-loving couple who enjoy travel and exploration. They are passionate about helping others and giving back to the community through various interests, including being host parents for St. Edwards exchange student program. Jesse also devotes his time to Buddy Break, a free Parents’ Day off/respite program where kids with various special needs have fun while their parents get a break from their ongoing care-giving responsibilities. Jesse truly loves to work with people from every background and from all walks of life!

Unparalleled Service

The Power Of A Team

The Reynolds Team of Compass is proud to be your trusted real estate experts serving the Treasure Coast of Florida. Since 2006, we have been helping clients buy and sell homes in some of the most beautiful and sought-after communities including Vero Beach, Sebastian, and Hutchinson Island.

Our Team of highly experienced and knowledgeable real estate agents has over 90+ years of combined experience. The Reynolds Team is consistently ranked as the top Realtors in Vero Beach and surrounding areas with 1,000+ homes sold from 2019-2022. Our Team of full-time Realtors and dedicated support staff are committed to helping you achieve your real estate goals. We have the processes and programs in place to ensure an extraordinary client experience, whether you are buying, selling, or investing in real estate. When it comes to Real Estate in Vero Beach, we do more, and The Reynolds Team has over 500 Five-Star Google and Zillow Reviews to prove it.

Experience matters. The Reynolds Team has been selling homes in Indian River County and St. Lucie County since 2006. Looking to buy or sell a home on Florida’s East Coast? We’ve got you covered.

Meet The Team (772) 321-2113

Get an Instant
Home Value Estimate

What’s My Home Worth?

Get Started

Vero Beach Market Updates

Real Trends 2022

Ranked #1 in Vero Beach

  • 357+ Homes Sold in 2022
  • $164M+ Sales Volume in 2022
  • #10 Ranked in Florida in 2022
    by Real Trends
  • 90+ Years Combined Experience
Our Recent Sales


Our Featured Areas

Find a Home


Vero Beach Area Market

Get in on the Latest Listings

View All

Check Out Our

Google Reviews

The Reynolds Team

(772) 321-2113
Office: 1701 Highway A1A, Suite 104 Vero Beach, FL 32963

Let's Connect

Join my list of insiders and be the first to receive exclusive listings and market updates.

Contact Us

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
(772) 332-4119